黑料网

Attitudes among Elderly towards Complementary and Alternative Medicine use as a Suicide Prevention Program in Korea: A Preliminary Study

Bethsaida Yanain Rojas¹, Eric Richardson², Dong-Hyun Ahn^3*

¹College of Medicine, Hanyang University, Seoul, South Korea.

²Graduate School of Biomedical Science & Engineering, College of Medicine, Hanyang University, Seoul, South Korea.

³Department of Neuropsychiatry, Institute of Mental Health, Hanyang Center for Behavioral Development, Hanyang University, Seongdong-gu, Seoul, South Korea.

*Corresponding Author:

Dong-Hyun Ahn
Director, Department of Neuropsychiatry
Institute of Mental Health, Hanyang Inclusive Clinic for Development Disorders
Hanyang Center for Behavioral Development, College of Medicine
Hanyang University, 222-1, Wangsimni-ro, Seongdong-gu
Seoul, 04763, South Korea
Tel: 82-222908425, 82-1037449090
Fax: 82- 222909471
E-mail: adndh@hanyang.ac.kr

Received date: April 13, 2017; Accepted date: April 19, 2017; Published date: April 24, 2017

Citation: Rojas BY, Richardson E, Ahn DH (2017) Attitudes among Elderly towards Complementary and Alternative Medicine use as a Suicide Prevention Program in Korea: A Preliminary Study. J Tradit Med Clin Natur 6:216.

Copyright: © 2017 Ahn DH & Rojas BY, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.

Visit for more related articles at Journal of Traditional Medicine & Clinical Naturopathy

Abstract

Introduction: Suicide among Korean elderly persons continues to be a major issue, with most suicides being in the over 65 years old demographic population. It has the highest suicide rate of all Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) member countries and ranking 31st out of 38 member nations in terms of overall life satisfaction. It is well known that depression is the psychiatric diagnosis most strongly associated with suicide; therefore, the aim of this research was to explore how to address depression using Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) among senior citizens.

Methods: A cross-sectional study was conducted among 326 subjects aged 65 years and over, attending senior citizen halls located in Seoul, Korea. The survey instrument was designed to explore whether CAM is a good adjuvant in suicide prevention programs within senior citizen halls. Data entry was done by using Excel and exported to SPSS version 21.0 software package for analysis.

Results: Among 326 participants, 93.3% reported using one or more CAM modalities for depression-related outcomes. Prayer, traditional Korean medicine, sports, diet, medicinal herbs and fungi were the leading complementary and alternative therapies used to improve mood disorders. Almost half of respondents, 49.7% used some complementary health therapy while receiving conventional depressive treatment.

Conclusion: The findings support the urgent need to resolve the social problem of suicide among elderly population, especially isolated elders. CAM appears to be widely accepted and used by a high percentage of Korean elderly people to improve mood disorders. Most herbs were self-prescribed and undisclosed to health care providers. This result highlights the need of in-depth study into Complementary Health approaches and their potential effects as adjunctive treatment for elders at risk of suicide.

Keywords

Depression; Suicide; Prevention; Elderly; South Korea; Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM)

Introduction

Despite South Korea’s economic success over the past several decades, the generation of elderly responsible for its economic miracle has been poorly rewarded. South Korea has received the nickname as “suicide capital of the world” partly because so many of its elders end their own lives and due to the rise of suicides rates, to date the problem persists [1]. Despite policies to reduce this number, it has the highest suicide rate of all Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) member countries (28.1 per 100,000 in 2012, while the average rate for all of the OCED countries was 12.1), topping all other nations for more than a decade [2].

Rising poverty among the elderly correlates with an increase in their suicide rate from 34 per 100 thousand persons in 2000 to 72 in 2010, far above the OECD average of 22 deaths per 100,000 populations. Onehalf of Korea’s population aged 65 and over lives in relative poverty, nearly four times higher than the OECD average of 13% [3]. The high elderly poverty rate reflects the decline in family support before other private and public sources of old-age income have matured. Korea ranks last in supporting its elderly population and is the least prepared to care for its rapidly aging population among the OECD countries. Many elderly assumed that their children would care for them, thus making it unnecessary to prepare financially. The increase in the number of elderly living alone–from 0.54 million in 2000 to 1.25 million (a quarter of the elderly) in 2010–also indicates declining family support. South Korea has the fastest aging population among the advanced economies and the factors shown to lead elderly to commit suicide are economic hardship, unemployment, psychological despair, physical pain and family problems. In the near future, when 30-year-old Koreans become 65, the country’s employment rate for the elderly is expected to top 40%, with more than 7.3 million elders aged 65 years and older participating in economic activities. The rise in the elderly employment rate comes as life expectancy increases, as most retirees are unprepared for a longer life after retirement. Korea’s life expectancy was around 77 years in 2002, but it is expected to rise to 82.5 years in 2020 [3,4].

The issue of “suicide and depression” has had an economic impact on the nation. The costs derived from suicides and depression increased 42% between 2007 and 2011 to 10.4 trillion won (10.2 billion dollars). About two-thirds of that comes from lost potential income and nearly a third from the consequent fall in productivity [5]. By the year 2020, depression is projected to show the second greatest increase in morbidity after cardiovascular disease, inducing a significant socioeconomic burden [6]. Depression in the elderly increases the risk for medical illness and is often missed and untreated, resulting in fatal consequences [7]. Some studies report a low degree of willingness to express suicidal thoughts by the elderly, while others suggest that the absence of treatment in those elderly with depression is associated with the occurrence of suicide attempts [8]. It is well known that depression is a leading factor linked to self-destruction; therefore, addressing clinical depression and improving psychological well-being of the elderly may be beneficial in preventing suicidal ideation and reduce suicide risk by implementing community-based prevention [9].

To date, research related to suicide prevention and intervention strategies using Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) has been limited to programs conducted for veterans, military personnel and prisoners. However, no research has been undertaken to assess the attitudes and perceptions toward use of CAM as a strategy to prevent suicides among elderly people. This paper describes the quantitative evaluation of the perceptions and attitudes among the elderly population regarding the use of CAM, whether its use could be implemented as a strategy within senior citizen halls to prevent suicides and for increasing their quality of life. The study aims were to evaluate the current knowledge, prevalence and preference of CAM use in a sample of Korean elderly aged 65 years and over that use the senior citizen halls, the application of CAM as an adjuvant in suicide prevention programs within senior citizen halls, and its relationship with social demographic characteristics.

Methods

Research design

This research was a cross-sectional and descriptive study collecting quantitative survey data. The questionnaire consisted of Closed-Ended and Open-Ended Questions written in Korean.

Research area

This study was carried out in Seoul, South Korea from January to August 2016 among 326 elders, attending Senior Citizen Halls (SCH), in Korean “???”. Seoul city has 25 districts, with a total of 3338 facilities at the time of the study. Although there are existing Suicide Prevention Programs running for the last several years at Elderly Welfare Centers, many elderly that attend the neighborhood Senior Citizen Halls do not attend Elderly Welfare Centers due to many factors including distance, convenience, economic factors and attraction to the environment of the facility. From the available Senior Citizen Halls, four were selected from the official data of the [Korean CDC], three from among the districts with the highest suicide rates, and one from amongst the districts with the lowest suicide rates.

Study population

The study population was apparently healthy elderly aged 65 years and over, being free from any terminal illness, willing to participate in the survey and living in the selected districts. Sample size was calculated using the single population proportion formula as follows: n=zm²·p·q/e² [10].

Sampling method

The survey was divided into two stages, the first one was cluster sampling, a total of forty-eight senior citizen halls were selected. Second, the number of participants per Senior Citizen Halls was proportionately determined based on the total number of SCHs and total members per hall in each selected district.

Data collection

Elders who met the criteria received the information in verbal form about the research and those persons willing to participate in the survey gave consent and filled out the questionnaires. Participants were interviewed by the principal investigator, three Korean teachers and eight Korean interviewers with previous experience in interviewing elders, who were trained to administer the questionnaire and taught on CAM as defined in the questionnaire. Participants were offered two options for completing the survey: either independently completing the survey, or being interviewed and asked each question by the interviewer.

Quality control

The questionnaire was pre-tested among twenty elders over 65 years old, workers from Hanyang, Korea, Seoul and Hanguk Universities to check ambiguity, incomprehensible and leading questions. Following the pilot-test’s feedback, the survey instrument was rewritten and restructured six times; the translation was made and reviewed by two Korean students of English language and a Korean English teacher.

Data analysis

The closed-ended questions from the questionnaires were initially coded using Microsoft Office Excel and transferred to the Statistical Package for the Social Science (SPSS) v.21 for analysis. Chi square test for single variance, P-values, and logistic regression’s tests for comparison of variables were used to compare categorical groups. Quantitative data was summarized and analyzed with descriptive statistics and results was expressed as percentage, organized and presented using frequency tables.

Ethical considerations

Ethical approval was obtained from the Institutional Review Board on Human Subjects Research and Ethics Committees, Hanyang University and the additional permissions were requested to each Senior Citizen Hall selected. The survey was conducted under privacy, confidentiality and the questionnaires were anonymous. To ensure voluntary participation from each participant, an informed consent form signed was obtained from them.

Results

Socio-demographic characteristics

The population included in the analysis for this study was 326 subjects between 65-96 years old from Senior Citizen Halls (SCH). No participant was discarded because the survey was not selfadministered; the research was conducted one by one (interviewerrespondent) (Table 1).

Table 1: Social demographic characteristics.

Prevalence

Overall, 93.3% (n=304) of the participants that reported depressive feelings or those diagnosed with depression have used one or more complementary therapies as a personal treatment.

Preference

The most commonly used alternative or complementary therapies by elders were prayer 22% (n=67), traditional Korean medicine 16.4% (n=50) sports 12.9% (n=39), diet 8.9% (n=27) and medicinal herbs and fungi 8.3% (n=25). Although the findings indicate a broad selection of CAM practices, for the majority of the participants the perceived efficacy of their preferred CAM modality was positive (Table 2).

Table 2: CAM use satisfaction.

Distance between participant home and welfare facility

The majority of users 98.5% (n=321) responded that the most convenient facility in terms of distance from home and comfort was the Senior Citizen Hall. The results showed that 43% (n=140) of participants have used the services of SCH for a period of five to ten years, 31.9% (n=104) one to five years, followed by periods of less than 1 year 15% (n=49) and more than ten years 10.1% (n=33) respectively. Elders most commonly use the SCH facility daily 34% (n=111), followed by 3 weeks in the month 32% (n=104), and 2 weeks per month 23% (n=75), and averaged spending from 4 to 10 h per day there 60% (n=198). The rest of the population was spread out between less than 4 h per day or more than 10 h per day.

Decision to use the Senior Citizen Hall (SCH)

Elders reported the following reasons for using the SCH, in descending percentages: loneliness (51.5%), meeting new friends (13.8%), boredom (11.7%), engage in activity for enjoyment (10.7%), others (8%) and for learning (4.3%) respectively. They report feeling the following benefits from visiting the SCH: “I am not alone and I have friends” (95.4%), followed by “I forget my problems when I stay in SCH” (89.9%), “I can trust and express my feelings and thoughts” (54%).

Attitudes

In the surveyed population, nearly half (49.8%) report that they believe programs and activities that teach and promote CAM at the SCH would be helpful to improve the quality of life and help learn how to deal with problems that lead to depression. Only (14.3%) of the respondents disagree with this statement (Table 3).

Table 3: Attitudes regarding to use of CAM to treat mental illness and preventing suicide.

Discussion

This research provides a first estimate of the prevalence of use and knowledge toward use of CAM treating depression among Korean elderly, as well as, the attitudes for developing suicide prevention programs using CAM in Senior Citizen Halls.

The World Health Organization (WHO) recognizes “suicide” as a public health priority accounting for more than half of the world’s 1.5 million violent deaths annually [11]. In 2013, the 66^th World Health Assembly, with 194 Member States, adopted the WHO’s Comprehensive Mental Health Action Plan 2013–2020, the first in its history. The plan sets a central role for provision of community based care and emphasis on human rights, and in addition, promotes moving away from a purely medical model to address various social factors including income, education, housing, and other social service, that impact on mental health as a more comprehensive [12]. South Korea has implemented Strategies to Prevent Suicide (STOPS), a program of “initiatives aimed at increasing public awareness, improving media reporting of suicide, restricting access to means, screening and improving treatment for persons at high risk of suicide.” This program includes national guidelines for media coverage to focus more on warning signs and possibilities of treatment, rather than factors that lead to suicide [13]. Various CAM modalities can provide social and non-traditional interventions in relation to these programs.

The use of alternative medicine modalities as an isolated therapy is uncommon because most people use non-mainstream approaches along with conventional medicine, which is more accurately defined as complementary medicine. Alternative medicine would be defined as treatments that replace conventional medical care in toto [14]. Evidencebased data that suggest CAM therapies are effective adjuvants for treating mental health disorders. Evidence-based integrative complementary medicine treatment models, such as ALPS (Antidepressant-Lifestyle- Psychological-Social) [15] have been previously used to treat clinical depression (characterized by psychophysiological changes in energy, sleep, appetite, low mood, feelings of worthlessness or guilt, loss of pleasure and/or suicidal thoughts) [16]. Other studies show physical therapies such as Tai Chi and physical exercises have a positive effect on maintaining elders’ mobility and thus are beneficial to maintaining mental health [17-19]. Research of Korean senior citizen halls found that community programs for better quality of life and improved physical and mental health are satisfactory and successful if the population served participates in their selection and planning [20-23].

Globally, the use of CAM therapy for various kinds of diseases is continuing to increase across many cultures, social backgrounds, and across all ages for multiple and diverse reasons, so it is important to know the prevalence of use and current knowledge on CAM to address the epidemic of depression and suicide among the elderly. It is especially important to document the use of CAM that is occurring alongside allopathic medicine, to know the efficacy of the various therapies and prevent negative effects that could come from the unreported combining of therapies.

The results of our research show a high prevalence of CAM use (93.3%), alongside a surprisingly low level of knowledge (36.9%) concerning their use by healthcare providers. In addition (49.7%) of CAM users were taking concurrent prescription medication, a high percentage compared to another study showing that 13% of participants were taking herbs along with allopathic medicine, obtaining as a presumed result higher depression and anxiety scores than other herb users [24]. This imbalance between use and knowledge will seriously affect the health of those elderly who use CAM to treat their symptoms of depression caused by problems other than mental illness. Ventegodt and Merrick have suggested that even for patients with serious mental and physical disorders, nondrug CAM therapies appear to be safe [25]. The use of CAM is likely not the problem, instead it is the low level of knowledge towards what they are using, especially the use of phyto-therapeutics that is not communicated to their doctors; it is a dangerous combination. This finding is in agreement with a previous study, suggesting that the prevention of negative herbal-medicinal interactions requires training healthcare personnel to obtain more detailed patient information regarding CAM usage, especially oral and other physical therapies [26].

Mind/Body Interventions Therapies (44.1%) to treat symptoms of depression were the preferred CAM treatment among elderly people in our study; these include prayer (22%), sports (12.9%), humor therapy (4.3%), and dance and music therapy (3.6%). Other studies support the findings in this research, indicating that mind and body practices relieve the symptoms of depression and provide benefits in mood alterations [27-31]. The second most used group of CAM modalities were Biologically Based Therapies (28.4%), which includes diet (8.9%), medicinal herbs and fungi (8.3%), dietary supplements (6.9%), and megavitamin therapy (3.3%); these therapies, including dietary changes, belong to the natural product therapies. These results are in agreement with a previous study, showing that 34% of patients used herbal medicines to treat mood disorders, that most of these patients self-prescribed the herbal remedies and their use was undisclosed to their healthcare providers [24]. Significantly, Traditional Korean Medicine (16.4%) was the most used alternative medical system, which is within the group of other approaches (16.7%). These results provide compelling evidence for the integration of CAM into Evidence-Based Clinical Practice.

Information about CAM use was commonly obtained from family (21.5%), advertising on TV, streets, buildings, etc. (17.8%), others (traditional market) (14.7%), oriental medicine healthcare workers (13.5%) and friends (11%); similar results have been reported from a National Survey in 2006 in a general population in South Korea [32]. Regarding reasons for CAM use, the main cause was: “dissatisfaction toward allopathic medicine and/or treatments were not available for a specific illness” (39.8%), “traditional background, belief in the alternative system and individual philosophical viewpoint” (16.9%), “others” (in case of hearing good comments on certain alternative therapy or personal experience of positive side effects) (16.3%), and “a hope for fewer side effects” (14.4%). A lower but significant percentage were motivated by economic factors believing that ”alternative medicine is cheaper than allopathic medicine” (4.6%), others began complementary therapies out of curiosity (4.6%) or by recommendation from a medical doctor (3.4%). These reports suggest that the use of CAM may be positively influenced by culture, background, family, friends, environment and oriental medicine healthcare workers. These results found are similar to other studies done [33,34].

Our research clearly shows that the elderly perceive CAM as a helpful adjunct to help treat mental illness and prevent suicide (64.8%), and would recommend the use of CAM (64.4%) to someone with suicidal thoughts. The factors statistically associated with perceptions toward use of CAM for suicide prevention were predicted by previous attitudes when treating symptoms of depression using alternative therapies, age, and marital status, accompanier of residence, income and health insurance. Regarding to attitudes: Age, income, health insurance and their perceived effectiveness of complementary and alternative treatments for mental health, were the independent predictors. In this respect, the strongest predictors were an average monthly income between 2.5-5 million won (p-value ≤ 0.001) perceived effectiveness (p-value ≤ 0.001) and previous attitudes (p-value ≤ 0.001) toward using CAM for mental health. Our observations are in agreement with findings of the WHO traditional medicine strategy 2002-2005, where it is mentioned that in most developed countries the use of CAM appears to be related to factors other than cost and tradition, because the traditional medicine use is quite different from country to country and region to region [35].

Despite South Korea’s status as a developed country, there are people with “low income, no income nor health insurance” and that population turns to alternative medicine for the most common reasons: necessity, affordability and accessibility. This is also in agreement with the WHO traditional medicine strategy 2014-2023, wherein factors such as low income, inadequate education, poor health and inequality (found in high proportions in developing countries), force the populace to use alternative therapies because they are cheap, available and accessible [36]. This suggests that regardless of whether individuals are lower or higher income and education, with or without health insurance, young or old, in search of “just health” or “a good human life with quality,” people are using CAM to achieve that purpose. Therefore, we conclude our hypothesis that perceptions and attitudes among Korean elderly people toward use of CAM as an adjuvant in suicide prevention programs within senior citizen halls to help to decrease suicide rates was found positive.

Limitations

Three districts studied have the highest elderly’ suicide rate in Seoul (2010-2014), and one district among the lowest suicide rate, but not nationally. Therefore, the results do not represent the whole aging society of South Korea.

Conclusion

The study gave a perspective of knowledge, use, attitudes and perceptions towards use of CAM as a preventive strategy in senior citizen halls to help to reduce suicide risk. It may be helpful for the understanding of elders’ concerns, expectations and anxieties about the research question. This information may be helpful in assisting to know how to decrease the older people’s suicide rate through CAM program research conducted within senior citizen halls. Notwithstanding their limitations, this pilot study may generate new information or ideas as a contribution to the appropriate authorities, focusing on CAM use as a tactic for preventing suicides in senior citizen halls and the outcomes of this study may be helpful as a reference for future related studies.

Funding and sponsorship

This research was supported by Hanyang Institute of Mental Health.

Authors’ Contribution

Rojas BY wrote the proposal, participated in data collection, analyzed the data and drafted the paper. Richardon E and Ahn Dong- Hyun approved the proposal, participated in data analysis, revised subsequent drafts of the paper and approved the final manuscript.

Acknowledgments

We are very grateful to Hanyang Institute of Mental Health for financial support and to Institutional Review Board on Human Subjects Research and Ethics Committees, Hanyang University for approval of ethical clearance and technical support of this preliminary study. Then, we would like to thank the Korean senior citizens who participated in this study for their commitment in responding to our interviews. We are also grateful to those Senior Citizen Hall facilities who accepted participate, for their assistance and permission to undertake the research. Finally, our sincere thanks to the Koreans students and teachers for their great effort, especially to Lee Kwang-Il for his unconditional support during the survey.

References

1. Kwon JW, Chun HR, Cho SI (2009)
2. World Health Organization (WHO) (2012) Suicide rates by country. Global Health Observatory Data Repository.
3. Jones RS, Urasawa S (2014)
4. Jackson R, Howe N, Nakashima K (2010)
5. Hyun KR (2015)
6. World Health Organization (WHO) (2011) World Health Organization. Mental health: Depression.
7. NAMI National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI)
8. Kim SM, Ha JH, Yu JH, Park DH, Ryu SH (2014)
9. McGirr A, Renaud J, Séguin M, Alda M, Turecki G (2008)
10. Wayne WD, Chad LC (2013) Biostatistics: A foundation for analysis in the health sciences. Tenth edition.
12. World Health Organization (WHO)
13. Hendin H, Xiao S, Li X, Huong TT, Wang H, Hegeel U, Philips MR (2015)
15. Sarris J (2011)
16. APA American Psychiatric Association (APA) (2013) Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders.
17. Huh MD, Ha CK (2006)
18. Kim SJ (2007)
19. Chu SK, Lee CY, Yoo JH (2012)
20. Rim CS, Kim KH, Kim MS, Lee KH, Lee IS (2006)
21. Min BG (2006) The activate plan and the present status of hall for the old. Korean Academy of Social Welfare Support 2: 255-270.
22. Lee HW, Song YH, Lee JS, Choi SY (2005)
23. Lee JY, Kim EC, Sohn TJ (2005)
24. Edwards D, Heufelder A, Zimmermann A (2012)
25. Ventegodt S, Merrick J (2009)
26. McCrea CE, Pritchard ME (2011)
27. Yeung AS, Ameral VE, Chuzi SE, Fava M, Mischoulon D (2011)
28. Monti DA, Beitman BD (2010) Integrative Psychiatry. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
29. Muskin PR (2000) Complementary and Alternative Medicine and Psychiatry. Arlington, VA: American Psychiatric Press Inc.
30. Mischoulan D, Rosenbaum JF (2008) Natural Medications for Psychiatric Disorders (2nd edn.). Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
31. Koch S, Morlinghaus K, Fuchs T (2007)
32. Ock SM, Choi JY, Cha YS, Lee J, Chun MS, et al. (2009)
33. McFadden KL, Hernández TD, Ito TA (2010)
34. Da Silva TL, Ravindran LN, Ravindran AV (2009)
35. World Health Organization (WHO)
36. World Health Organization (WHO)